First Choice Charter Fishing

Experience Door County’s premier family fishing operation. Captain Todd Haleen is a Baileys Harbor native and 2nd generation captain with over 25 years experience. The “First Choice II” is an incredible 30’ custom fishing machine. The “Harbor Lights” boat is USCG certified for families or groups larger than six. Both are fully loaded with the finest tackle, fish locating, navigation, and safety equipment available. All ages are welcome!


Baileys Harbor Town Marina.


  • On Water

Fish Type

  • Brown Trout
  • Chinook Salmon
  • Smallmouth Bass
  • Walleye

Fishing style

  • Great Lakes Charters