Take A Bite Out of Wisconsin’s Amazing Pie
When you’re craving something sweet and made with love, look no further than Wisconsin’s homemade pie. From time-honored favorites to out-of-the-box flavors you can’t find anywhere else, discover where to find delicious slices throughout the state.
Stockholm Pie and General Store – Stockholm
A tour of Wisconsin’s best pie has to start with the award-winning Stockholm Pie and General Store in Western Wisconsin. Named “Best Pie Shop in America” for the second year in a row in 2025 by USA TODAY, travelers come from near and far to get a taste of these sweet and savory specialties.
Try flavors like Kentucky Bourbon chocolate walnut, lingonberry lemon and butterscotch cream, and explore the general store together for all kinds of local goodies.
Crystal Café – Iola
Family-owned for over 50 years, each pie at Crystal Cafe in Central Wisconsin is individually hand-rolled before being packed with delicious homemade filling. Visit to try tasty slices like coconut meringue, cherry crisp, Fireball whisky pumpkin and more. The cafe is also a full-service restaurant offering breakfast, lunch and dinner.
The Elegant Farmer – Mukwonago
The Elegant Farmer in Mukwonago is open year-round, but fall brings their Autumn Harvest Festival weekends, where families can enjoy additional activities such as pick-your-own apples, pumpkins and a corn maze. Be sure to try the trademark apple pie baked in a paper bag, which creates a unique, crunchy top crust and flaky bottom crust. Come for the pie, and stay for the fun!
Sweetie Pies – Fish Creek
Sweetie Pies in picturesque Door Countyoffers a wide range of pies perfect for every craving. From chocolate chip cookie nut to peach raspberry and the crowd-pleasing Door County Cherry, stop in the shop on your next trip for a homemade sweet treat.
Main Street Café – Bloomer
With a menu full of scrumptious options for breakfast, lunch and dinner, it may be difficult to leave room for dessert at Main Street Café in Northwest Wisconsin. But you and your crew will definitely want to leave room for slices of peanut butter Heath, rhubarb sour cream raisin and caramel apple crumb.
Found a favorite? Their pies can even be ordered in sheets—perfect for serving at your next party or special event!
Norske Nook – Osseo, Rice Lake, DeForest and Hayward
Known throughout the Midwest for their Norwegian specialties and delicious pies, Norske Nook offers guests a wide array of flavors sold by the slice or the whole pie. Whatever you choose, this traditional Scandinavian restaurant and bakery serves their delicious treats with a side of warm hospitality from servers sporting traditional Scandinavian attire.
With so many places to indulge in scrumptious pie (possibly rivaling grandma’s!), our list could go on and on. Here are some of our other favorites:
Lake Geneva Pie Company – Lake Geneva
Market Street Diner – Sun Prairie
C’s Bakery and Coffee Shop – Middleton
Still hungry? Keep your sweet tooth satisfied with Wisconsin’s official pastry: kringle.
Deals
