Settler's Inn Restaurant, Deli & Catering

Deli options

Deli options

Caramel Apple Trifle

Caramel Apple Trifle

Enjoy breakfast and lunch downtown in a 130-year-old historic building. Have your favorite beverage at our coffee and espresso bar. Our unique menu of chef-prepared food includes soups, salads, wraps, toasted sandwiches and burgers. Try our award-winning pies and desserts. Kids' menu and gluten-free options available. Relax with a glass of Wisconsin-brewed beer, homemade Sangria or our own Bloody Mary. Carry-out available, with outdoor seating in summer. Friday Fish Fry served until 7pm. Make dinner easy by shopping our frozen entrée section that includes our famous pot pies. Catering for personal parties to corporate events.

Hours of Operation

Monday-Thursday: 7am-5:30pm, Friday: 7am-7pm, Saturday: 8am-4pm. Breakfast served all day. Lunch starting at 11am. Kitchen closes at 3pm daily.


From Milwaukee: I-94 to I-43 North. Exit 89 Cedarburg/Hwy C. Go West on Hwy C approximately 3 miles to Washington Avenue. Turn right on Washington Avenue and continue to downtown Cedarburg. Located at the intersection of Cleveland St. and Washington.

Meals Served

  • Breakfast
  • Lunch

Restaurant Type

  • American
  • Gluten Free Options